Sunday, 19 February 2017

Personal Ranking: Best Supporting Actress 2016

Janelle Monáe really delivers in her two supporting debut roles this year. Which did I prefer?
Honourable Mentions:

The 20th Century Women (Greta Gerwig, Elle Fanning)
Fanning and Gerwig are both very good and absolutely infectious as Julie and Abbie, the two friends of Jamie (Lucas Jade Zumann) his mother (Annette Bening) recruits to help mentor him through 1970s America and his tumultuous teenage years. Fanning does a fresh take on the 'more experienced best friend' character and deftly steps between being unbearable and sympathetic, and has some great deadpan comedic scenes. Gerwig is heartbreaking in showing Abbie's hidden demons, but incredibly heartwarming in showing her passion in teaching Jamie about a vast array of topics she thinks will prove useful to him becoming a better person.

Kate McKinnon, Ghostbusters
I'll admit the film, in retrospect, is a bad film, poorly directed, poorly written, and the less said about the villain, the use of special effects and the cameos, the better. It's funny that the film was torn apart by people saying the casting of women would be the film's downfall, since half of the central quartet essentially save it from being a complete disaster. I found Kirsten Wiig a bit bland and Melissa McCarthy a bit forgettable, but Leslie Jones is quite funny in a poorly written part, and McKinnon, as Jillian the bizzare engineer, gets the most spontaneous comedic bits (no doubt largely improvised by herself) and is easily the highlight of the film. I wish a better film had been constructed around her.

Alison Sudol, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
Like McKinnon, Sudol's a real scene-stealer in Fantastic Beasts. although she's also in a much better film, and has Dan Fogler's, the endearing, bumbling Muggle (sorry, I refuse to use 'No-Maj') baker to play off and complement her delightful work. Sudol's Queenie Goldstein is essentially a combination of witch and 1920s flapper, it's an inspired combination and she reminded me a bit of a 1990s Miranda Richardson with her cheery grin, adorable innocence, a sweet sort of stupidity that never feels in poor taste, and makes her sweet litle romance with Jacob quite affecting by the film's end.

Zoey Deutch, Everybody Wants Some
My memory of the film has somewhat diminished, so I'm in need of a re-watch, but Deutch gives a pretty delightful performance as Beverly. It's a simple role really, but Deutch handles Richard Linklater's dialogue better than anyone besides Glen Powell, has sparkling chemistry with Blake Jenner, and makes her little segment in the film quite memorable.

Rachel House, Hunt for the Wilderpeople
House gives one of the downright funniest performances of 2016 as the overzealous child welfare officer Paula. Everything she does is so over-the-top and ridiculous and House makes it work so well, adding another hilarious element to the film. Her abrasive showoff with Ricky about the Terminator, her absolutely brutal verbal takedown of the police officers on Ricky's case, her hilarious appearance on a television talk show comparing Ricky to being a 'spanner in the works', her repeated invocation of 'no child left behind', even when she's just silently teaching people how to break necks swiftly, makes this an incredibly comedic performance I could bump up even higher in the future.

The Neon Demon girls (Abbey Lee, Jena Malone, Bella Heathcote)
This trio of vacuousness is one I hope work with Refn in the future since they all have such a wonderful grasp of his style. Malone, as probably the most 'human' of the lot, is a devilishly saucy delight as Ruby, the makeup artist with a thing for Jesse (Elle Fanning), and makes some of the more unpalatable elements of the film still work in her favour. Her breakdown to her character's final actions is particularly good. Lee gives probably the most stylized performance in the film, the supermodel who feels threatened by Jesse's entrance into the modelling world. She's actually quite heartbreaking in the scene where she shows an utter loss of faith in herself after losing out on a job to Jesse, and she also manages to make her transition into a bloodthirsty cannibal work particularly well, as she showed in Mad Max: Fury Road last year, she's definitely got presence. Heathcote has the least to do out of the three, but she gives such a memorably hollow, incisive performance, with everything she says feeling so false, and helps make the divisive ending of the film work somewhat.

Angourie Rice, The Nice Guys
Another film I barely remember anything about, she's nevertheless a fine and endearing presence as the wannabe detective daughter of Ryan Gosling's Holland March, making her sometimes convoluted and long-winded lines work, even though the highlight of the film is easily the two leading men.

Janelle Monáe, Moonlight 
She really is panning out to be quite the great actress, and I can't wait to see more of her work in general. This is her smaller of her two roles this year, but Monáe still makes a very big impression in a watertight ensemble as Juan's (Mahershala Ali) girlfriend Teresa. Her onscreen presence is just something very special in itself, she's a warm and supportive, and low-key funny presence in Chiron's life, and she's also part of the best acted scene in the film (the breakfast scene), helping to amplify Ali's incredible work in that scene with her honest reactions. 

Lucy Boynton, Sing Street
A very interesting performance that takes on the usual 'aloof grungy girl' vibe before peeling it away to reveal the insecurities underneath. Boyton's Raphina is a very well-written character so far as these sorts of characters go, and I found her performance effective in exploring the facade of her 'cold' exterior and her growing affection for Conor (Ferdia Walsh-Peelo).

Imogen Poots, Green Room
Hate to leave her off my nominees. Out of my early first-half-of-2016 picks for the acting categories, Poots stuck in for the longest till I watched Hidden Figures last week. Anyway, Poots gives a rather marvellous performance as a grungy witness to the central murder that kicks things off. I love how she plays Amber as essentially someone being forced to give a fuck (pardon my french) for something, alluding to the rough life of her character brilliantly and how she's become accustomed to it alongside her fear of the terrifying situation she's in. She completely dominates her scenes when required as she gradually asserts a mad, energetic approach to her survival and develops a great chemistry with Anton Yelchin's Pat.

Personal Ranking: (see http://actorvsactor.blogspot.co.uk/2017/02/ranking-oscar-nominees-best-supporting.html for my thoughts on Harris, Kidman and Davis.)

5. Janelle Monáe, Hidden Figures
Monáe is terrific here as the scene-stealer of the film, Mary Jackson, a computer at the segregated West Area Computing division who becomes NASA's first female engineer. Monáe stands out in the film beyond just having a great set of costumes and her spunky attitude, which is really unique and one of a kind. In that her sassiness and delivery of lines like 'I have the right to see the fine in every colour', her witty retorts to the bigoted police officer, and her energetic encouragement of her best friends in their various pursuits, are all so entertaining to watch. Then in her quieter scenes where she's dealing with her dream to become an engineer against all odds, and the disappointments along the way, I found her incredibly moving, particularly in her 'Oscar' scene where she asks the judge to grant her permission to attend classes at a white high school. I found she made a huge impression even in the somewhat limited narrative capacity we are given for her character. It's a truly entertaining performance but also moving and very nuanced in its own way. 

4. Naomie Harris, Moonlight 

3. Felicity Jones, A Monster Calls
It's funny that she's sandwiched between Harris and Kidman on my list, because where Harris presents the worst possible type of mother and Kidman the absolute best type of mother, Jones' portrayal of Lizzie, the ailing mother of Conor (Lewis MacDougall), is somewhere in between but also beyond the limits of those maternal figures. A Monster Calls is in many ways the film I think I wanted The BFG to be, in its depiction of a troubled child who finds a strange sort of mentor in a giant talking figure, Liam Neeson's titular monster tree. Jones depicts an absent mother figure, but not in the way you'd expect, in that she's absent against her own will, her terminal illness getting the better of her physically, and Jones is remarkable in depicting her physical breakdown in such a heartbreaking fashion. Alongside the deterioration of her health though, Jones finds something very special in the character's inner strength that never dissipates even in her final moments. She's very good in establishing her character's history with her ex-husband (Toby Kebbell) and her mother (Sigourney Weaver), suggesting a sort of distant love for both of them, and brings something truly special to her moments with MacDougall, as she dispenses maternal warmth and wisdom but in such a unique fashion. Her speech to Conor about 'breaking things' is absolutely devestating, and her final scene and reaction in the film hit me extremely hard. A great performance, and one I wish had gotten some awards traction alongside the underrated and financially under-performing film.

2. Nicole Kidman, Lion

1. Viola Davis, Fences
  1. Viola Davis, Fences 
  2. Nicole Kidman, Lion
  3. Felicity Jones, A Monster Calls
  4. Naomie Harris, Moonlight 
  5. Janelle Monáe, Hidden Figures
  6. Imogen Poots, Green Room
  7. Abbey Lee, The Neon Demon
  8. Greta Gerwig, 20th Century Women
  9. Jena Malone, The Neon Demon 
  10. Rachel House, Hunt for the Wilderpeople
  11. Elle Fanning, 20th Century Women
  12. Alison Sudol, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
  13. Bella Heathcote, The Neon Demon
  14. Lucy Boynton, Sing Street
  15. Octavia Spencer, Hidden Figures 
  16. Kate McKinnon, Ghostbusters
  17. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
  18. Janelle Monáe, Moonlight
  19. Angourie Rice, The Nice Guys
  20. Zoey Deutch, Everybody Wants Some!!
  21. Kirsten Dunst, Midnight Special 
  22. Golshifteh Farahani, Paterson
  23. Kim Su-an, Train to Busan 
  24. Tilda Swinton, Doctor Strange
  25. Haley Lu Richardson, The Edge of Seventeen
  26. Tioreore Ngatai-Melbourne, Hunt for the Wilderpeople
  27. Scarlett Johansson, Captain America: Civil War
  28. Tilda Swinton, Hail, Caesar!
  29. Teresa Palmer, Hacksaw Ridge
  30. Rachel House, Moana
  31. Elizabeth Olsen, Captain America: Civil War
  32. Anna Faris, Keanu
  33. Viola Davis, Suicide Squad
  34. Kyra Sedgwick, The Edge of Seventeen
  35. Sigourney Weaver, A Monster Calls
  36. Leslie Jones, Ghostbusters
  37. Kate Dickie, The VVitch
  38. Gal Gadot, Batman v.s. Superman
  39. Riley Keough, American Honey
  40. Jung Yu-Mi, Train to Busan
  41. Chloë Sevigny, Love & Friendship
  42. Alia Shawkat, Green Room
  43. Phoebe Fox, Eye in the Sky
  44. Diane Kruger, Disorder
  45. Shree Crooks, Captain Fantastic
  46. Rima Te Wiata, Hunt for the Wilderpeople
  47. Gina Rodriguez, Deepwater Horizon
  48. Nana Komatsu, Silence
  49. Emma Thompson, Bridget Jones's Baby
  50. Samantha Isler, Captain Fantastic
  51. Vespyr Cash, Captain Fantastic
  52. Brianna Hildebrand, Deadpool
  53. Yaya DaCosta, The Nice Guys
  54. Kathryn Hahn, Captain Fantastic
  55. Anne Consigny, Elle
  56. Naomie Harris, Our Kind of Traitor
  57. Leslie Uggams, Deadpool
  58. Sofia Boutella, Star Trek Beyond
  59. Emma Greenwell, Love & Friendship
  60. Sarah Solemani, Bridget Jones's Baby
  61. Rooney Mara, Lion
  62. Sophie Turner, X-Men: Apocalypse
  63. Kirsten Dusnt, Hidden Figures
  64. Rachel Griffiths, Hacksaw Ridge
  65. Rachel McAdams, Doctor Strange 
  66. Lois Smith, The Nice Guys
  67. Greta Gerwig, Jackie
  68. Scarlett Johansson, Hail, Caesar!
  69. Ahn So-hee, Train to Busan
  70. Morfydd Clark, Love & Friendship
  71. Chasten Harmon, Paterson
  72. Gabourey Sidibe, Grimsby
  73. Judith Magre, Elle
  74. Margot Robbie, The Legend of Tarzan
  75. Gemma Jones, Bridget Jones's Baby
  76. Morena Baccarin, Deadpool
  77. Iris Berben, Eddie the Eagle
  78. Zoe Salanda, Star Trek Beyond
  79. Rebel Wilson, Grimsby
  80. Isla Fisher, Grimsby
  81. Tiffany Haddish, Keanu
  82. Lupita Nyong'o, The Jungle Book
  83. Emayatzy Corinealdi, Miles Ahead
  84. Angela Bassett, London Has Fallen
  85. Han Ji-min, The Age of Shadows
  86. Charlotte Le Bon, Bastille Day
  87. Jenn Murray, Love & Friendship
  88. Samantha Morton, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them 
  89. Jenna Coleman, Me Before You
  90. Scarlett Johansson, The Jungle Book
  91. Alexandra Shipp, X-Men: Apocalypse
  92. Sienna Miller, High Rise
  93. Paula Patton, Warcraft
  94. Janet McTeer, Me Before You
  95. Holliday Grangier, The Finest Hours
  96. Jemma Regrave, Love & Friendship
  97. Alicia von Rittberg, Our Kind of Traitor
  98. Diane Lane, Batman v.s. Superman
  99. Lucy Russell, Toni Erdmann
  100. Kate Hudson, Deepwater Horizon
  101. Ingrid Bisu, Toni Erdmann
  102. Laura Linney, Genius
  103. Elizabeth Moss, High Rise
  104. Elizabeth Olsen, I Saw the Light
  105. Hayley Bennett, The Magnificent Seven
  106. Laura Linney, Sully
  107. Rebecca Ferguson, Florence Foster Jenkins
  108. Sela Ward, Independence Day: Resurgence
  109. Rebecca Hall, The BFG
  110. Anna Baryshnikov, Manchester by the Sea
  111. Maika Monroe, Independence Day: Resurgence
  112. Gretchen Mol, Manchester by the Sea
  113. Naomi Watts, Demolition
  114. Holly Hunter, Batman v.s. Superman
  115. Ana de Armas, War Dogs
  116. Radha Mitchell, London Has Fallen
  117. Rose Byrne, X-Men: Apocalypse
  118. Penelope Cruz, Grimsby
  119. Angelababy, Independence Day: Resurgence
  120. Kara Hayward, Manchester by the Sea
  121. Olivia Munn, X-Men: Apocalypse
  122. Kate Winslet, Triple 9 
  123. Karen Fukuhara, Suicide Squad
  124. Jennifer Lawrence, X-Men: Apocalypse
  125. Melissa Leo, London Has Fallen
  126. Amy Adams, Batman v.s. Superman
  127. Julia Stiles, Jason Bourne
  128. Nicole Kidman, Genius
  129. Cara Delevingne, Suicide Squad
  130. Kim Basinger, The Nice Guys
  131. Laura Linney, Nocturnal Animals

No comments:

Post a Comment